CocktailRecipes

Buttery Finger Recipe + Ingredients & Tips

how to make a Buttery Finger recipe

📋 Nutrition Facts
Main Alcohol Kahlua
Alcohol 20%
Calories 200 calories
Fat 5g
Protein 1g
Carbohydrates 15g
Prep time 5 minutes

Ever wondered how to whip up the perfect Buttery Finger cocktail or yearn for a sip of something truly refreshing? This article delves into the essence of the Buttery Finger, from its flavor profile to presentation, guiding you through a sensory journey that captures the emotional and thematic layers of this beloved drink. Join us as we unravel the magic behind the Buttery Finger. ⬇️

History

The Buttery Finger cocktail is a delightful concoction with a rich history. Originating from the playful experimentation of bartenders seeking to capture the essence of sweet, creamy desserts in a glass, its name and popularity quickly spread. This drink is a testament to the creativity and innovation found within the world of mixology.

  • The name “Buttery Finger” draws inspiration from the buttery notes of butterscotch and the playful idea of something so good it slips through your fingers.
  • It gained popularity in the late 20th century, becoming a favorite for its dessert-like qualities that appeal to a wide audience.
  • The cocktail’s evolution has seen it adapted in various forms, with each bartender adding their unique twist to the classic recipe.

The taste of a Buttery Finger

A Buttery Finger tastes like a liquid dessert. The sweet, creamy butterscotch flavors blend smoothly with the kick of vodka, creating a delightful balance that dances on the palate.

I personally love drinking Buttery Fingers because they’re incredibly smooth and offer a sweet escape, especially after a long day.

Interesting facts about Buttery Finger

  • The cocktail’s creamy texture is often achieved without the use of actual cream, showcasing the mixologist’s skill in balancing flavors.
  • Despite its dessert-like taste, the Buttery Finger can be quite potent, thanks to the vodka base.
  • It is a versatile drink, easily adapted to suit various tastes and occasions.

Ingredients

  • Vodka: 1.5 oz (45ml)
  • Butterscotch Schnapps: 1 oz (30ml)
  • Irish Cream: 1 oz (30ml)

A rocks glass is typically used when serving a Buttery Finger, as its wide brim allows the aroma of the butterscotch to tantalize the senses before the first sip. An alternative could be a martini glass, which adds an elegant touch and showcases the drink’s rich, golden hue.

Recipe. How to make Buttery Finger

  1. Pour 1.5 oz of vodka, 1 oz of butterscotch schnapps, and 1 oz of Irish cream into a shaker filled with ice.
  2. Shake well until the outside of the shaker feels cold.
  3. Strain the mixture into a rocks glass filled with ice.
  4. Garnish with a cherry or a small swirl of cream, if desired.

Buttery Fingers, with their sweet, indulgent flavor, can be a bit heavy on sugar and calories. For a healthier twist, consider using natural sweeteners or low-calorie alternatives for syrups. While the alcohol content does bring certain health considerations, enjoying a Buttery Finger in moderation can fit into a balanced lifestyle.

Rate this recipe


Food Pairings

Certain foods can elevate the experience of enjoying a Buttery Finger, complementing its rich flavors and creamy texture. Here are some suggestions:

Chocolate Desserts

The sweet, buttery notes of the cocktail match wonderfully with the decadence of chocolate, making for an indulgent pairing.

Salted Nuts

The saltiness of nuts can contrast and enhance the sweet, creamy elements of a Buttery Finger, adding a delightful crunch.

Cheese Platters

A selection of cheeses, especially those with a creamy or sharp profile, can complement the cocktail’s richness and add complexity to the tasting experience.

I really enjoy the taste of Buttery Fingers—the cool, creamy texture and sweet flavor make it a perfect drink for unwinding.

🍸 Mix up your beverage routine
Receive the freshest cocktail recipes and bar trends directly in your inbox.
Please enter a valid email address
That address is already in use
The security code entered was incorrect
Thanks for signing up

Bartender Advice

  • Chill your glass before serving to enhance the Buttery Finger’s refreshing quality.
  • Experiment with the ratio of ingredients to find your perfect balance of sweetness and strength.
  • Using high-quality butterscotch schnapps can significantly elevate the drink’s flavor profile.

Now that you’ve mastered the classic Buttery Finger, in the sections below we’ll shake things up by showing the customizable elements you can alter and introducing a range of exciting variations to try in your next concoction.

What you could change in Buttery Finger

  • Butterscotch Schnapps: Can be replaced with caramel liqueur for a different type of sweetness.
  • Vodka: Consider using flavored vodka to add another layer of taste.
  • Irish Cream: A dairy-free alternative can be used for a lighter version.

Buttery Finger Variations

Caramel Swirl Buttery Finger

  • Ingredients: Use caramel vodka instead of plain and add a splash of heavy cream.
  • Recipe: Follow the base recipe, topping with a swirl of caramel sauce.

Spiced Buttery Finger

  • Ingredients: Add a dash of cinnamon and nutmeg to the base ingredients.
  • Recipe: Shake with ice and strain into a cinnamon-sugar rimmed glass.

Chocolate Buttery Finger

  • Ingredients: Add chocolate liqueur to the base recipe.
  • Recipe: Garnish with chocolate shavings or a small chocolate bar.

To enjoy a non-alcoholic version of a Buttery Finger, simply mix butterscotch syrup with a dash of cream and soda water. Serve over ice for a refreshing, sweet treat.

Q&A

Can I make a Buttery Finger without alcohol?

Absolutely, using butterscotch syrup and cream, you can create a delightful mocktail version that captures the essence of the original cocktail.

Is there a vegan option for a Buttery Finger?

Yes, by substituting the Irish cream with a dairy-free alternative and ensuring your butterscotch schnapps is vegan-friendly, you can enjoy a vegan Buttery Finger.

How can I adjust the sweetness of my Buttery Finger?

Playing with the ratio of butterscotch schnapps and Irish cream, or adding a touch of milk can help balance the sweetness to your liking.

What’s the best time to enjoy a Buttery Finger?

While it’s perfect as an after-dinner drink, its versatility means there’s never a wrong time to indulge in a Buttery Finger.

Can I batch make Buttery Fingers for a party?

Yes, you can mix the ingredients in a larger quantity and store it in the fridge. Serve over ice when ready to enjoy.

Are there any health benefits to drinking a Buttery Finger?

In moderation, the joy and relaxation it brings can be beneficial. However, it’s wise to be mindful of its sugar and alcohol content.

Chris Glazer
Chris Glazer
Chris Glazer is a seasoned mixology and cocktail recipe writer at CocktailPlans.com. Chris has a deep passion for cocktail creation and mixology, and has been exploring and writing about the world of drinks for over 5 years.
Similar Cocktails 🍹

Muff Diver

Recipes
The Muff Diver is an adventurous and playful cocktail, often served in a unique way with a blend of fruity flavors that dance on the palate. It is a delightful concoction that combines the sweetness of liqueurs with a creamy touch, making it a favorite for those who enjoy a spirited and lighthearted drink experience.

Orange Flip

Recipes
The Orange Flip is a creamy and smooth cocktail, blending the bright taste of orange with the richness of egg and a touch of sweetness. It's a frothy delight, often enjoyed as a sophisticated, non-alcoholic treat.

Buttered Toffee

Recipes
The Buttered Toffee cocktail is a rich and creamy delight, blending the deep flavors of toffee with a smooth touch of buttery goodness. It is a decadent treat that combines sweetness and warmth in a sophisticated, sippable form.

Dirty Mexican

Recipes
The Dirty Mexican is a warm, chocolatey cocktail with a spicy tequila twist, often enjoyed as a dessert drink. It combines rich flavors in a smooth blend that leaves a pleasantly surprising kick on the palate.

Blonde Russian

Recipes
The Blonde Russian is a creamy and sweet concoction with a smooth vodka foundation, elevated by the luxurious taste of coffee liqueur and a splash of cream. It provides a velvety texture that gently dances on the palate, offering a sophisticated twist to the classic White Russian.

Captain Crunch

Recipes
The Captain Crunch cocktail is a whimsical, dessert-like drink that tastes remarkably similar to the beloved cereal, blending creamy and fruity flavors for a nostalgic sip. It is a delightful concoction that offers a playful twist, combining the comfort of childhood memories with the sophistication of an adult beverage.