Peanut Butter Cup Recipe + Ingredients & Tips

how to make a Peanut Butter Cup recipe

📋 Nutrition Facts
Main Alcohol Vodka
Alcohol 20%
Calories 350 calories
Fat 15g
Protein 5g
Carbohydrates 25g
Prep time 4 minutes

Imagine you’ve just discovered the secret to the perfect drink, a treasure hidden in a glass. The Peanut Butter Cup cocktail is an adventure in flavors, combining sweet, nutty, and chocolatey notes to delight your senses. Let’s dive into its fascinating history, delectable taste, and how you can craft your own at home. Get ready to shake, stir, and sip your way to cocktail bliss! ⬇️

History

The Peanut Butter Cup cocktail, a recent invention, has no deep historical roots but quickly became a favorite for its dessert-like qualities. It mirrors the rise of sweet, indulgent drinks that appeal to a modern palate seeking comfort in a glass. Despite its newcomer status, it has made a significant impact on the cocktail scene, proving that simplicity can often lead to perfection.

  • The name Peanut Butter Cup is inspired by the popular candy, aiming to replicate its rich taste in liquid form.
  • It was likely concocted by a creative bartender looking to translate the beloved peanut butter and chocolate combination into a cocktail.
  • Its popularity soared with the advent of flavored liqueurs and the trend of dessert-inspired cocktails.

The taste of a Peanut Butter Cup?

Take a sip of the Peanut Butter Cup cocktail, and you’ll be greeted by a creamy blend of peanut butter and chocolate, reminiscent of the famous treat. It’s a sweet, velvety concoction that feels like a dessert and a drink rolled into one comforting embrace.

I find the Peanut Butter Cup cocktail irresistible because it’s like sipping on my favorite candy, transforming a simple treat into a sophisticated indulgence.

Interesting facts about Peanut Butter Cup

  • The cocktail’s ingredients can be adjusted to accommodate different levels of sweetness and nuttiness, depending on the drinker’s preference.
  • Some bartenders use actual peanut butter in their recipes, creating a richer, more authentic flavor profile.
  • It’s a versatile cocktail that can be enjoyed on the rocks or blended into a frozen delight.

Ingredients 📃

  • Peanut butter liqueur: 1.5 oz (45ml)
  • Chocolate liqueur: 1 oz (30ml)
  • Cream: 0.5 oz (15ml)
  • Vanilla vodka: 1 oz (30ml)
  • Garnish: Chocolate shavings or peanut butter cup

A martini glass is the best vessel for serving the Peanut Butter Cup, as its wide brim showcases the aroma and allows the flavors to fully envelop the palate. Alternatively, a rocks glass could also be used for a more casual presentation.

Recipe. How to make Peanut Butter Cup 🍹

  1. Fill a shaker with ice and pour in 1.5 oz (45ml) of peanut butter liqueur and 1 oz (30ml) of chocolate liqueur.
  2. Add 0.5 oz (15ml) of cream and 1 oz (30ml) of vanilla vodka to the mix.
  3. Shake the ingredients vigorously until well-chilled.
  4. Strain the mixture into the chosen glass and garnish with chocolate shavings or a mini peanut butter cup.

While the Peanut Butter Cup cocktail is a treat, it’s wise to enjoy it in moderation due to its sugar and calorie content. For a healthier twist, consider using natural sweeteners and low-fat cream without sacrificing the decadent flavor.

Rate this recipe


Food Pairings

Discover the perfect food companions for the Peanut Butter Cup cocktail; these pairings will elevate your drinking experience to new heights, creating a symphony of tastes that complement each other beautifully.

Chocolate Desserts

Indulging in a chocolate brownie or a slice of chocolate cake alongside the Peanut Butter Cup cocktail can amplify the chocolate notes and create a truly luxurious treat.

Salted Nuts

The salty crunch of mixed nuts or specifically salted peanuts can contrast and balance the sweet richness of the cocktail, offering a delightful textural experience.

Fruit Platters

Fresh fruit like strawberries or bananas can bring a refreshing and slightly acidic counterpoint to the creamy, dense flavors of the Peanut Butter Cup.

I adore Peanut Butter Cups; they’re a sweet escape into a world of creamy, chocolatey bliss.


🍸 Mix up your beverage routine
Receive the freshest cocktail recipes and bar trends directly in your inbox.
Please enter a valid email address
That address is already in use
The security code entered was incorrect
Thanks for signing up

Bartender Advice

  • Always chill your glass beforehand to keep the cocktail cool and enhance the flavors.
  • For a smoother texture, fine-strain the cocktail to remove any ice shards or peanut bits.
  • Experiment with the proportions of peanut butter and chocolate liqueur to find your perfect balance.

Now that you’ve mastered the classic Peanut Butter Cup, in the sections below we’ll shake things up by showing the customizable elements you can alter and introducing a range of exciting variations to try in your next concoction.

What you could change in Peanut Butter Cup

  • Cream: Can be substituted with non-dairy alternatives for a vegan-friendly version.
  • Vanilla vodka: Try using espresso vodka for a coffee twist on the original flavor.
  • Peanut butter liqueur: For a less sweet option, use a smaller amount or replace it with a nutty syrup.

Peanut Butter Cup Variations

Spiked Peanut Butter Hot Chocolate

  • Ingredients: Peanut butter liqueur, chocolate liqueur, hot chocolate, whipped cream.
  • Recipe: Mix the liqueurs into hot chocolate and top with whipped cream for a warm, comforting twist.

Peanut Butter Cup Martini

  • Ingredients: Peanut butter liqueur, chocolate vodka, chocolate syrup, milk.
  • Recipe: Shake ingredients with ice and drizzle chocolate syrup in a martini glass for an elegant touch.

Frozen Peanut Butter Cup

  • Ingredients: Peanut butter liqueur, chocolate liqueur, vanilla ice cream, milk.
  • Recipe: Blend all ingredients until smooth for a frozen, milkshake-like version of the cocktail.

A Virgin Peanut Butter Cup can be just as delightful. Mix chocolate syrup with peanut butter and milk, then shake and pour over ice for a non-alcoholic treat.

Q&A

Can I make a Peanut Butter Cup without alcohol?

Absolutely, just swap the liqueurs for non-alcoholic alternatives like syrups, and enjoy a mocktail version of this treat.

What if I’m allergic to peanuts?

You can use almond butter or sunflower seed butter as a base for your cocktail to avoid any issues, but always be cautious and check the labels of your ingredients.

Is this cocktail suitable for a large party?

Sure! Just multiply the ingredients by the number of guests and mix in a large batch. It’s a sweet hit that’ll have everyone talking.

How can I make the Peanut Butter Cup cocktail less sweet?

Try reducing the amount of liqueurs or cream and consider adding a splash of milk to dilute the sweetness.

What’s the best time to serve a Peanut Butter Cup cocktail?

It’s perfect as an after-dinner drink or when you’re in the mood for a dessert with a kick—anytime you crave something sweet and comforting.

Can I store leftover Peanut Butter Cup cocktail?

It’s best enjoyed fresh, but you can store it in the fridge for a day. Shake well before serving again to ensure the flavors are well blended.

Chris Glazer
Chris Glazer
Chris Glazer is a seasoned mixology and cocktail recipe writer at CocktailPlans.com. Chris has a deep passion for cocktail creation and mixology, and has been exploring and writing about the world of drinks for over 5 years.

Thai Tea

A Thai Tea cocktail is an exotic blend, combining the creamy sweetness of traditional Thai Tea with a smooth touch of spirits such as rum or vodka. It is a delightful fusion that tantalizes the taste buds with its spiced, milky flavors and a gentle alcoholic warmth.

Frozen Mudslide

The Frozen Mudslide is a creamy, chocolate-flavored cocktail with a rich blend of coffee liqueur, vodka, and Irish cream. It's like a decadent dessert in a glass, perfect for sipping on a warm day.

Sloe Screw

The Sloe Screw is a smooth, fruity cocktail that blends the rich, berry-like flavor of sloe gin with the bright, citrus tang of orange juice. It offers a delightful mix that is both comforting and zesty, perfect for savoring on a relaxed afternoon.

Raspberry Lemon Mule

The Raspberry Lemon Mule is a zesty and fruity beverage that combines the tang of fresh lemons with the sweetness of raspberries, topped off with a spicy ginger beer fizz. It's a colorful and lively drink that tickles the taste buds while delivering a gentle warmth.

Rum Flip

The Rum Flip is a smooth, creamy cocktail with a rich blend of rum, sugar, and a whole egg, topped with a sprinkle of nutmeg. It's a classic, warm concoction that offers a comforting, velvety taste experience.

Woo Woo

The Woo Woo is a fruity and vibrant cocktail, blending the sweet, tart taste of peach with the sharpness of cranberry, all smoothed out with a dash of vodka. It's a playful yet simple drink that delights with its bright color and refreshing zing.